Papa Johns Pizza

12/26/25 Carry out. Hope Papa's keep the Grand Papa around for awhile! Excellent thinner crust, xx large pepperoni, 3 cheese, We got black olives, perfectamundo! Large tasty mild deli size pepperoni, 8, x-tra x-tra large foldable pieces. Best Pizza yet for us anyway! Thanks Papa John's! We like bbq so we drizzled some Kinders original bbq sauce once we got home, wow! So good!!!

I ordered the Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites. I had not tried them before. They come with your choice of dipping sauce. I chose cheese. Absolutely delicious. They are so good that I let my grandson and a friend try one. They also agree. Delicious. My friend will now be going to Papa John's to order these bites. Oh and the dipping sauce, I thought it was better without any. Definitely recommend.

I use Uber. I received a 51 dollar order. Two pepperoni pizzas and a Philly cheese steak with black olives. Well I recieve 12 black olives a 3.90 upgrade and two awful pepperoni pizzas. I did call about the cheesesteak pizza because of the lack of black olives. The person I talked to had no idea what she was doing and the "manager" wasn't available. Anyways that pizza was good. The pepperoni pizzas are so bad I'm throwing them out. The pepperoni doesn't even taste right.i Don usually complain. But seriously and hardly any sauce. I'm very discouraged and will not get papa johns from Greencastle Indiana again

Everyone always has a smile and they make great pizza. Always quick for pick up.

Ahamid took my order over the phone in a different country I go to pick it up there's 7 employees just standing at the register and none of them would help me they all just kind of wandered off and had the woman that was actually working come help me? Then I get home with my Philly pizza and it's a cheese pizza with peppers on it and 2 small pieces of meat! Not good service and would not recommend or try again!