Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry FL

Man Mikey throws DOWN in that kitchen!! I whether there’s a lunch special or not, it’s always worth the time to stop in. My server was a doll (Yolie) and just so sweet! Do not fear for any tiny portions here, EVERYTHING was decent. I get gluten free pies here for my bestie and it is fantastic, doesn’t taste gritty like gluten free foods usually do.

I ordered to take away this penne pasta with shrimp the truth the portion was for two people because of the amount of pasta but only brought the dish 6 shrimps and it was disappointing for me, and the pasta lacked flavor or salt, what I liked the most was the bread that came additional with this dish. It wasn't bad but it wouldn't be a dish I would order again.

My friend and I pop in every 3-6 months and the place doesn't feel like it disappoints. The portions are filling and the staff give good service. I wanna say that if you order anything on the menu (dinner menu) you have to be hungry. On our recent visit we came in to try some sandwiches as we thought those would be light. Not sure why I did it, but I ordered the AlexSandwich the Great and my friend got an Italian Combo. Getting a side with a sandwich is extra but when you see it you know why. The sandwiches are served open face a look huge. The AlexSandwich the Great felt like it could be split among two people, add an order of some garlic knots and you would be happy. If anything that if a good sandwich to have before going out drinking as your stomach will be padded.

This place should’ve been named “Delicious Anthony’s”, seriously! The food is always amazing, I haven’t been here (in person anyways)since 2018 and the service is even more stellar than it was pre-Covid, my server Rachael was an absolute doll to have, my shy daughter even came out her shell around her. Great dine in experience and amazing food! Been high recommending since 2016!

AMAZING. I’ve been to a lot of restaurants, I’ve searched for the best sauce in central Florida. When I tell you that this was the best Italian food I have ever eaten in my life, I promise you that is not an understatement. Even the house wine was amazing! BEST SAUCE BEST PIZZA BEST SERVICE BEST ATMOSPHERE. That is not an exaggeration! I want to thank Anthony’s for making one hell of a meal tonight & I also want to thank Sammi for the best service I have had in a long time. Thank you!