Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Went at beginning of lunch had a great server. Our appetizer and pizza was really good. The salad was basic but the dressing was good. I didn't care for the doughnut bites but the they come with chocolate and caramel dipping sauce. They also have two other dessert options. I'm just a particular desserts person so try them yourself.

The pizza was great, we had the hand tossed Chicago 7. Bonus that they had a parking lot. The guy who helped us was very nice but not very engaging. The pizza did take awhile to come out but definitely worth it!

Maybe it's because I ordered to go. The pizza was terrible. The chicken on the pizza was over cooked, hard and too tough to chew. The wings were good but not 10 bucks for 5 good. The service was great I will say but Old Chicago is going to be a hard no for me. 30 bucks wasted.

I’m honestly shocked this place calls itself Old Chicago Pizza. The pizza I received was completely undercooked — the crust was still doughy and soft, like it never even finished baking. The chicken tenders were just as bad; the breading fell right off as soon as I picked one up. To make things worse, instead of refunding my money, they only offered store credit. Why would I want to come back after that experience? The pizza was tiny for a “personal pan,” especially for $13. I’ve had better frozen pizzas from the grocery store. Old Chicago should be embarrassed to serve food like this. Easily the worst pizza I’ve ever had

I’ve been here a few times but never reviewed it. I’ve always been pleased with the food. This was surprisingly the first time I ordered the pizza which was very good. Thin crust though. I’ve had Chicago style in Chicago and I don’t care for all that dough.