O Sole Mio

The Sicilian Pizza crust is is so good! I ordered sausage, Pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, kalamata olives, extra cheeses.. This pizza was so good!! And they don't scrimp on the sauce! This is the way pizza is suppose to taste! Sicilian Style! Yum Yum go get ya some!!

Authentic NY/Jersey pizza pies!! Finally found some tasty east coast pizza at this lively little haunt on Vashon Island! The large pizza was actually a LARGE pizza unlike so many of the twinkie “large” pies around here! Plain classic cheese was 28 bucks! Perfect crust and sauce/cheese ratio😋 Staff were pleasant and efficient. Had a glass of wine while waiting for the order and enjoyed the near constant hum of chatting of patrons and music…definitely worth the ferry ride!!!

LET ME START OFF BY SAYING THE PIZZA 🍕 WAS HOT AND GOOD, THIS IS LIKE THE THIRD TIME I'VE BEEN AND UNFORTUNATELY IT WILL BE MY LAST... THE DEAL-BREAKER FOR ME IS THE CASHIER IS TAKING CASH PAYMENTS WORKING THE REGISTER AND IS GRABBING PIECES OF PIZZA BREAKING THEM APART PUTTING THEM ON PLATES AND SERVING THEM WITH THEIR BARE HANDS WTH WHERE THE HELL DO THEY DO THAT AT??? OBVIOUSLY HERE, THE LAST TIME I CAME THE GENTLEMAN AT THE REGISTER DID THE SAME THING, SO I POLITELY ASKED THE YOUNG LADY NOT TO TOUCH MY PIZZA WITH HER BARE HANDS, SHE SEEMED TO HAVE AN ATTITUDE AFTER THAT BUT IT'S LIKE COME ON FOR PETE'S SAKE YOU'RE WORKING A REGISTER A CASH REGISTER AND THEN TAKING YOUR DIRTY HANDS AND TOUCHING PEOPLE'S FOOD AND SERVING THEM EWWW🤮 MAYBE OTHER PEOPLE DON'T MIND IT OR ARE JUST TO QUIET T

Great taste (smoky bread taste, not hard cracker) crispy crust pizza with fresh & flavorful toppings, 5 star caesar salad, and delicious lasagna, in a generous portion, enough for 2!. Delicious. Our go-to place for NYC style bar, great pizza & Italian sides. Yum!

Delicious NY style pizza! The slices are very large. We ordered pepperoni slices and later purchased a whole cheese pie for take out the following day. The rest of Vashon is quite expensive and this felt like great food for a more reasonable price.