Nonna's Pizzeria

Honest to God, I'm done with this place. One too many awful experiences here. The state of our cheese pizza this evening was a disgrace. Looked like it had been transported here on the windshield and then thrown at my front door, just get a load of the photos. UPDATE: Slice / the restaurant did at least refund the pizza. So I've changed the service from 2 to 4 stars. That's something at least.

While there is no shortage of places to get pizza in Yorktown Heights, I find myself a regular at Nonna's. Plenty of parking, tables, and outdoor seating. The food is constantly good. I particularly like their salad slice, while others may have salad slices pre made, Nonna's always makes to order, which ensures a crisp, warm slice of crust topped with fresh salad. It makes all the difference that they take a little extra care.

Tried here on a whim because we were in the area. My daughter said the sauce reminded her of the pizza in her school cafeteria. The cheese was rubbery and artificial tasting. The dough had zero crispiness. I don’t understand any of the good reviews.

Pizza is delicious and so much variety. Plenty of seating and customer service to me is the most important, and this place has excellent customer service! Come by, you won't be disappointed!

09/24/23 11:28 We stopped in for a quick slice before attending a local wedding. Both service and pizza here is top notch. We had white pizza which had fluffy ricotta on mozzarella. (The best of this style we ever tasted!) Parking is plentiful. Seating is comfortable and the bathroom was spotless. Yes, we plan on another visit to your pizzeria.