Nick's Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria And Bar

As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur 🍕 (yes, I take my slices very seriously), I had to check out Nick’s Pizza. Let’s start with the good: the pizza was CHEESY and I mean that in the best way. Nice melt, good stretch, and they’ve got a great selection of specialty slices you can grab on the fly, which I always appreciate. Being able to try different combos by the slice is a win. Now… here’s where my inner pizza critic had some thoughts. The pizza was really acidic …. like, wake-you-up acidic and the sauce tasted a bit like it came straight from a bargain canned aisle. It kind of overpowered everything else going on. The wings had solid flavor (credit where it’s due 👏), but texture-wise they felt like they might’ve taken a second trip through the fryer. Not terrible, just not fresh-fr

Best pizza i have ever eaten, and I'm old. I had to travel to PCB for a "real" Brooklyn style pizza. When I was in New York, the pizza I got was not good at all. We had a slice of 3 different pizzas, meat lovers, chicken Parmesan, and Sicilian. Words cannot describe how flavorful they were. The cheese is incredible, the meats are so fresh. We tried the garlic knots. They were good, but nothing outstanding.

Amazing pizza! Nick’s serves up authentic NY-style slices that are huge, flavorful, and perfectly cheesy. The God Father slice is a must-try, and the garlic knots are out of this world. Friendly vibe, great service—definitely worth the stop in PCB

Pizza is a must anywhere I travel. Walking into Nick’s we felt welcome. I thought this would be another over hyped tourist spot on Google but it wasn’t. The pizza was some of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. This is truly Brooklyn style pizza not just claiming to be. We browsed the case of pizzas & made our selection. Garlic knots, spinach pie , sausage pizza, slice of the chicken parm pizza & a slice of margarita pizza. Service was top notch and just the right amount of personal touch. 👌🏾 Everything was delicious the garlic knots were piping hot and all the pizza slices were fresh and delicious. If I’m in PCB again in the future I’ll be sure to stop back by.

Nick’s Pizza is, without question, the best pizza in PC/PCB. Honestly, it’s the only place we even consider getting pizza anymore. Everything tastes incredibly fresh. The sauce, the cheese, the crust - you can tell real ingredients are used and cared about. And don’t skip the baked ziti… It’s absolutely to die for!!! Tonight made us love this place even more. The owner, Nick himself, came out and talked with us and treated us like family. He was so kind and genuine, and it says a lot about a restaurant when the person running it cares that much about customers. Thank you Nick!!!!