Newburgh Station Pizzeria

Everything we ordered was good overall. I did wish the pizza crust wasn’t as dry. The flavors were on point, and we really enjoyed the cheese bread and garlic puffs. The butter paneer pizza was yummy! The shawarma pizza was nice but felt more like alfredo pizza. I mean I liked it. The dipping sauce was . Maybe some pickles, the right spices and a nicer crust would make it more flavorful. Overall, we enjoyed our food!

A medium veggie pizza with Italian sausage added- Made perfectly- Ample amounts of toppings- crust had a nice chew- I watched him slice a fresh tomato for my pizza- nice a cheesy- good pull when hot Sweet chili chicken DELICIOUS!! Better than I remember three years ago. Sweet with heat.- plenty of chicken, green pepper, lots of bacon, and a loaded with cheese- yuuuuuum! Pic 3 Chicken tikka masala was delicious! YUM! The curry flavor comes through nicely but not overpowering- I appreciate that they put toppings from end to end- pic 2 Flaming tandoori chicken- Tasted so good- Crust has nice chew- Toppings from end to end- They weren’t light on the toppings - Wasn’t a fan of the ranch flavor- pic 1 New Owner- Very nice-

Unreal experience with Newburgh Station, as this was my first time. I placed an order a day in advance for 9:30pm delivery the following day. The lady calls me at like 8:30 and asks if she can bring it earlier because it’s her husband’s 50th birthday! Of course I said yes! She was so sweet, happy birthday to him 😆🙌

Haven’t been here in years but was craving the pickle bread. New owners since my last visit, offering Indian-flavored pies! I tried the butter paneer pizza and it did not disappoint. Excellent flavors 🤤. I’ll be back

TLDR: Amazing pizza, high-quality ingredients, authentic Indian flavors, wonderful staff! I just tried this place for the first time for lunch and was so blown away by the Paneer Tikka Masala pizza that I came back for dinner and had to order a whole smorgasbord. The pickle pizza came highly recommended to me (and rightfully so), so I had to get that in addition to their other Indian fusion pizzas. All told their paneer and their chicken is out of this world flavorful, and each of the 3 types of Indian fusion pizzas offered are distinctive, authentic, and perfectly balanced. The dough is also worth mentioning, as it is perfectly crunchy with just the right chew, and the garlic butter was amazing on that crust. When I showed up to pick up my dinner order, I was recognized from my earlier