New York Pizza (Grand Bay)

Omgoodness best pizza, Alfredo manicoti! Pizza by the slice! Pickle pizza! Hot honey cup pepperoni pizza! Just delicious Italian place! Oh and the tiramisu is wow! I was so surprised when I moved to this lil town of Grand Bay to find this jewel. I love pizza y'all though, I'm just saying

I’m in love with your pizza!!!!! We get slices to go at least 2-3 times a week. When did you start packing slices between paper plates?

Eat here all the time. Love the food. Only issue I’ve ever had is I reminded an older staff member that prep gloves are required for ready to serve food. And that the kid prepping a hot pizza went from the point of sale back to hot prep without washing his hands. The issue wasn’t so much the no gloves. It was her response that they don’t have to use prep gloves if it goes back in the oven. If I’m Rite or wrong you don’t go from a cash register to food prep without washing. And her response should have simply been. “I’ll talk to the staff and make sure they wash there hands between pos and prep” not defense.

My fiancé and I love this place! Today we ordered lunch. I got the blackened shrimp Alfredo add spinach and tomatoes with fries. He got the chicken Alfredo pasta. We both enjoyed our meals so much! Very delicious, great atmosphere, and outstanding service! I recommend New York Pizza in GrandBay to everyone!

Expect to wait forever. Even when the place looks empty, they are consistently 30–40 minutes behind their "estimated" pickup or delivery times. When the food finally arrives, it’s almost always lukewarm or flat-out cold. The crust is soggy, the toppings are cheap, and overall it’s just subpar pizza that tastes like it’s been sitting under a heat lamp for an hour. The biggest issue is the ownership. The people running this place are just not good people. They are rude to customers, dismissive of complaints, and I’ve seen them treat their own staff with zero respect.