New York Cupcakes

From the moment we walked into this super cute cupcake shop, we were greeted by Jaden and Tia. They were incredibly kind and friendly, and they helped me choose my cupcake flavors and decide how to decorate my birthday cake. I also ended up purchasing a few cupcakes, and they were absolutely delicious! I can't wait to try my birthday cake when I pick it up this Friday. I’ll definitely be back to New York Cupcakes 🧁 — I give them a 100/100! The service was amazing, the bakery smelled incredible, and I loved the atmosphere. It’s just so cute and welcoming! Jaden and Tia are amazing — they truly made us feel at home 💖💖💖💖

The owner made my wedding cake which was the delicious almond raspberry two tier! Then I had 100 cupcakes with a variety of flavors for my guests! She came and set everything up and it turned out beautiful!!! I enjoyed going back to the maker to try more flavors to see which ones I wanted for my guests! Everyone loved them!! Still my favorite cupcake bakery! Highly recommend!!!

Came in here with my wife for the first time and the lady at the counter stated that they had the best cupcake in town. She was indeed right. This was truly the best cupcake that we’ve had in Washington. Not overly sweet and bread was moist just to our liking. Will definitely be back again.

I'm really disappointed with the lack of consistency of their treats. I bought day old and I mean seriously, these just never taste the same twice, WHAT IS GOING ON!! The employees I spoke with had terrible customer service! they spoke to me in such a condescending way as if I don't know what I am talking about and tried to make a fool of me. I will not be coming back here there's plenty of better mom and pop shops with HUGE customer satisfaction rather than this place. I recommend buying from Safeway or Fred Meyers at least you know they will taste the same there :(

I ordered 18 regular in 2 flavors and a dozen mini cupcakes in 3 flavors for my kiddo’s bday party. I chose NY Cupcakes partly due to price, as you can get more cupcakes and have more choice of number of flavors when ordering in bulk compared to a couple known Seattle stores, and I made the drive over from Seattle. Service was excellent with tips on wrapping the boxes in plastic wrap since I was serving the cupcakes the next morning. When I showed the staff some fondant toppers I ordered externally, they were direct about not inserting the toppers too early since the cake is soft. The cupcakes tasted delicious. I would order them again any day, and if I wasn’t ordering primarily for kids, I would have liked to have tried more flavors! Also, the shop smells great and is beyond cute!