Nancy's Restaurant

First time here and atmosphere was very nice. It's right by the beach and went there during sunset time so the sun rays were beaming through the windows. Our server did share with us things that were their too sellers but since it was my first time at Marth's Vineyard, I wanted to try the lobster rolls. It was ok. I've tried better lobster rolls in the south. Their alcoholic drinks were a bust. They were $15 for a regular sized plastic cup. It wasn't mixed well and it was super bitter. My lobster roll was overpriced, I believe it was almost $30 for mediocre lobster roll. My bf got a cheeseburger and said it was nothing to jump up and down for. View was nice though.

This is a good stop for lunch at Oak Bluffs. We ordered online and when we picked it up they forgot our waters, didn’t ask if we wanted ketchup or tartar sauce. Overall the food and atmosphere was good but I will try a different place next time

We got the fisherman’s platter to share. Fries were great. Seafood was good except the whole belly clams. It could have been our first time eating them and not knowing what to expect but they were gross. Kids got cheeseburgers and they were affordable and tasted fine. Location is great, right on the harbor. If you are lucky enough to get a shaded bench, you could sit for hours and people watch. Bar onsite and makes dirty bananas that seemed to be very popular.

Nancy’s is a comfortable place, the staff is very humble and the situation is scenic. The food was good, but expensive. We had hummus and pita n fried calamari as starters. In the main course the lobster roll wasn’t very good, just loaded with too much butter. The baked Cod with the veggies was excellent

Mixed results here - the butter based lobster roll was a bit unfortunate. It was missing a good amount of butter. The mayo version tasted better. The onion rings are thin but good. Don't get quahog - it's all bread stuffing.