Mythical Pizza

This place was totally awesome! Everything from the service to the atmosphere was 10 out of 10. It truly is a little hidden gem! If you haven't been there, definitely stop! So many different options, great price! I was thoroughly impressed with the quality of the pizza! And the two ladies that were working really knocked it out of the park!

Not your typical pizza joint. It has a cool cryptid theme decor and food. A huge variety of gourmet pizza as well as the usual standards. The staff was helpful when we had questions. The food was prepared efficiently and came boxed ready to eat in or take out. After eating in we decided to give the dessert menu a look and ended up ordering dessert and extra to take home it all looked so good.

Just moved to Hedgesville, but sometimes visit Berkeley Springs. Two days ago I decided to try a pizza from here, and it was so good, that I ordered a pizza the very next day. The first one I had was slightly softer on the bottom crust than I prefer, and just a little too greasy, but it did not ruin the pizza for me. It was still phenomenal. The second pizza we had was cooked perfectly on the bottom, the first one wasn’t undercooked, it just was a little softer/greasy than I prefer. I love that they play Christian music in there, it wouldn’t bother me if they didn’t, but I enjoyed the fact that they do. Both times I went in It was a completely different staff, and both days the staff was very personable and had great customer service. I’m already thinking of what creative pizza I will have

Love the idea of this place, loved the pizza customization options, and even thought the theming was fun. The endlessly updating quiz was entertaining while we waited for our food. But the vibe otherwise felt a bit off. Staff seemed unenthusiastic. Arcade wasn't working. That all would have been just fine except the pizzas all seemed to be rather undercooked for the amount of toppings and cheese. It tasted alright, for sure, but definitely could have been made better with better proportionality..

This is my first time here as I was told by a family friend to check this restaurant out! I’m sure glad that I listened to them. When you walk in you have to find an open spot and you’ll be ordering your meal from a large tablet. The decorations will give you another type of vibe! It’s just like if you were ordering at a Sheetz or any other large gas station. I decided to order the Cauliflower crust pizza, and my pizza was the “E.T.” as each pizza has its own individual name. As for the tablet there are a lot of options to put on your menu compared to a traditional Italian restaurant. Not to mention, my family member ordered chicken wings extra crispy and they enjoy them. The pizza was really good and the crust was burnt at certain spots, but beggars can’t be choosers. This pizza was full