Mystic Market LBI

The King Louis XII was amazing! So good i came back next day and got it again! The bacon wrapped lobster bites were just okay though. I wish i had requested them to be warmed up like i did for the lobster roll which makes it better. The sauce with the bacon wrapped lobster bites is kind of like a bbq sauce and just didn’t fit. It’s located in this quaint little sandwich shop vibe spot and while it doesn’t offer much the staff is nice. Will definitely be back every chance i get!

I’ve been coming to LBI for the past 10 years and I can’t believe I’ve missed this lobster roll 🥴 they have like 10 different versions…I’ve tried the Connecticut (pictured here) and the Maine. Both delicious with hearty lobster meat and visible claws, it comes only with a pickle and coleslaw but you can get a side of fries. My husband got the breakfast sandwich which he said was one of the best he’s ever had — quite the compliment because he can be a BEC snob ha. We will definitely be back!!!!

Lobster 🦞 roll options are amazing 🤩 I tried 3. All perfectly made. Pork roll was more like cooked sliced ham but loaded and great with hot sauce. Fantastic service and clean. The only issue in peak season would be parking. My wife who is not a big fan of lobster 🙄 loved the lobster taco 🌮 with guacamole. 🥑

I’ve been coming here for years for lobster rolls it’s a staple for me and my husband. But today set the bar high and just reminded me why I constantly will support this business (not only for their outstanding lobster rolls). I live an hour and a half away from the beach and it was our first trip of the season with our new puppy, only to realize I left his food at home when we got on the island. I just needed a few slices of turkey to hold him over and the gentleman behind the counter was so nice about it and didn’t make me order a full sandwich, or a meal! Truly appreciate the kindness! Can’t wait to come back in 2 weeks! (Our pup begging for more turkey in the car haha he loved it) thanks so much!

Everyone was extremely nice. Place is very clean and the food is amazing! We got 3 10" Italian subs and it was big enough to feed 6 people for lunch on the beach. They also have fresh butchered meat and seafood! Perfect place to get what you need to make a surf and turf grilling experience! The even have lobster rolls, and they're reasonably priced compared to other places in the area! We will certainly be coming back here when we're in the area again! Wonderful experience and I highly highly recommend them!