Bageleddi's

Best bagels on the island and probably as close to NYC or north Jersey bagels as you’ll get down the shore. New owners (yes I know they’ve been the new owners for 2ish years now) increased the size of the bagels compared to previous owner (they’re now an average size) but maintained the boil and bake method and overall quality. Great staff, even when it looks busy moves quick. Slightly more expensive than mainland but worth it imo

Ate my bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel so fast, not pictured. Was a decent wait but was worth it.

I went to Bageleddi's with my fiancé on a Saturday morning. It is located in Ship Bottom and is a across the street from the beach. The place was packed so that was a good sign to me that it must be good. I ordered an iced coffee and a breakfast sandwich called the Fat Eddie, and my fiancé ordered a latte. As we sipped our drinks and I waited for the the staff to call my name for the sandwich, I observed that the staff was very efficient and friendly. The Fat Eddie breakfast sandwich was awesome. I figured it better be the best breakfast sandwich I'd ever have since it was priced around $15 dollars. I was right. I will definitely order it again. Bageleddi's is a great place to get bagels, coffee and breakfast sandwiches. Higher priced for high quality and convenience, being across from

Fantastic place. They have a wide variety of bagels, sandwiches, pastries/baked goods to choose from. I talked to the owners a bit (family owned) and they seems very nice too - which counts. I have a few bagels and egg sandwiches and they were great. I don't think they have seating there and they only take cash. However, they do have an ATM inside. Update. Went here a few more times and still extremely happy with the food and service. Meet the owners (Donna and Tommy) and had a couple nice conversations with them. Update 6/25/18: New location across the street. Bigger with outdoor seating and some yard games. Air conditioning now too!

Best bagels on LBI!!! Fresh, crisp and often warm and right out of the oven. Management changed prior to 2023 but service has gotten even better plus their bagels have gotten larger! Great breakfast sandwiches & muffins too.