Mr. P's Pizzeria

My daughter and I are obsessed with sausage and ricotta on pizza, and she actually keeps a running top 10 list of our favorite pizza jawns. Mr. P’s holds the #1 spot! The crust is hands down the best we’ve ever had, and the herbed ricotta is incredible. It’s always a treat when we’re in town, and Amanda is the best. We’ve never had anything but a great meal here! ✨

Told us to sit wherever we wanted then made us move to another table. Only a couple other folks were there. Pizza slices were messed up, she even said they were but gave them to us anyway. If that's what they serve and are fine with that sad service, I'll go elsewhere. Pizza was just o.k. better than little Ceasars.

Since moving to Delaware from Philadelphia, I have been searching for some good pizza. Well I found it today! This is the best pizza down here. Absolutely incredible Pizza. The crust is crunchy the cheese is perfect and they're hand cut fries are excellent. Hats off to Mr. P's!!

Great no nonsense pizza place. Cash only. Grabbed some localcraft beers at the bar as we waited for that delicious pizza.

Been wanting to stop here for a while. While on a bike ride from Rehoboth my wife and myself stopped for lunch. Great little place with a great beer selection. Now to the pizza! One of the if not the best pizza I have ever had. I am a sucker for wood fired pizza and this pizza is amazing. Their sauce is light and delicious mixed with the cheese and fresh mushrooms and wood fired!!! Bravo! Thank you for the experience. We will definitely be back! 12/01/2025 Still the best pizza in the area! One of my highlights on our trips down!