Montauk Seafood Grill

Our visit here was amazing! We chose here to celebrate our engagement and they did not disappoint! To start off we got the Hatteras marg and Cindy lou who 2, both of which had amazing flavor! Next the Hamachi ceviche which was the most tender citrusy fish I’ve ever eaten. It had the perfect amount of spice from the Serranos and citrus from the juice mmmm so good. The Lump crab cakes were so tender and flaky packing with flavor as well, so so good. Onto the main course we got the Ahi seared tuna, the tuna itself was perfectly cooked with a delicious flavor, the stir fry that came with it was good but not something I finished due to the lack of flavor. My fiancé got the halibut and lobster mac and cheese. The halibut had a perfect tasty crust with a flaky and soft inside, the mashed potato’s

Just returned from dinner. I read so many reviews ahead of time. 1st off we walk in and are greeted very coldly by the maitred. No warm inviting hello smile etc just blah. We sit down and waiter seems to be of the same disposition strange. We order the tuna poke which was good. Warm sourdough with citrus honey whipped butter was tasty. Grilled Salmon with 2 sides whipped mash and sticky rice and grouper with mash and Brussels sprouts was ok. The food is basic & tasty. Was the $$ warranted well we are in vail far from the sea and prices are known before we made reservations. Are there better restaurants in vail, yes. We had the sand pie many reviewers went back and forth on this. It again was just ok. Vanilla rice cream slice on gram cracker with warm chocolate and toffee sauce. For $16 we

Very good. Just be willing to spend some bucks. But, you won’t leave hungry. We got the ceviche, sourdough, ahi tuna, and sea bass. And everything paired so well. OH! And the vanilla ice cream cake with port wine. Delish. Brian was our server and he was great.

Restaurant itself was beautiful and upscale, had kids menus and coloring pages. Service was a little slow but otherwise great. The crab cakes appetizer was delicious. The kids crab legs were delicious, however it ended up being $85 for a kids meal, which is absolutely outrageous! The tuna was pretty bland, and the dessert was clearly just a frozen pre made piece of ice cream cake. The food was no where worth the money. Would not recommend.

Absolutely amazing experience! The food was incredible — everything we ordered was full of flavor and came out perfectly prepared. We came during happy hour and the deals were great, with a really nice selection that made it easy to try a few different things. The atmosphere was also fantastic: lively, welcoming, and the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a great meal. A huge shoutout to our server, Marianna, who truly made the night even better. She was so friendly, attentive, and made sure we were taken care of the entire time. Her recommendations were spot on and she had such a positive attitude that made the whole experience feel special. Between the delicious food, great happy hour, fun atmosphere, and outstanding service, we’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend!