Molly's Shebeen Bar + Restaurant

Oh my god. This place is so cool. Amazing tavern atmosphere with low ceilings and dim lighting making it super rustic and cozy. I had a chicken pot pie here that rocked my entire world and can’t wait to eat again. The service was alright and everything else was super stellar. A perfect package of a restaurant. Definitely recommend for a good meal and a lively atmosphere. I came here on a Sunday in a party of two for dinner and was seated with no wait. The football game was on and lots of people were gathered at the bar to watch the game on their two big screen tvs. 10/10 would eat here again.

Great Irish Pub in NYC! I was in town for a work event and I had a day off. As a player of Irish Sports, I wanted to visit a great Irish Pub in NYC and the reviews on Reddit all pointed to Molly Shebeen's. After a stroll through Madison Park, I made it to Molly's and was greeted with a smile from the bartender. I ordered a Guinness to start and it came out cold and quick. I looked at the menu and because of the rainy day, Shepherd's Pie seemed like the ticket. My food came out in less than 10 minutes and it was hot (the bartender warned me). It was delicious and hit the spot. No BS ingredients, hearty vegetables, good size chunks of ground beef, and very delicious. I also appreciated all the Gaelic sport photos and Irish Cultural items on the walls, and not a bunch of green shamrocks and

Went for a lunch break and they had a nice crowd and atmosphere as it was holiday season. Their fish and chips were hearty, fresh and crispy. Tartar sauce was great. And, I ordered a side of curry for extra dipping, which I highly recommend if you like a bold kick. Can’t wait to come back to try more of the food menu as it looks like authentic Irish cuisine.

Stopped in here for brunch as we gave up looking for places that didnt have ques out the door ( we visited on a busy period) food was fresh and homemade with good portion sizes but pretty average taste wise. Service was slow to get food and to get the bill but there was only one waitress working and it was busy so im guessing she could of used some help. I liked how it was decorated with all the lights inside it made it feel festive and cosy.

Dave was as welcoming as could be. Your classic, quintessential Irish pub. Authentic. Everything looked great. The shepherd’s pie was perfect, especially paired with a coffee.