Minico's Italian Restaurant

First Time Tonight! Waitress was really nice! Wife’s salad was not the best! Pizza Pepperoni and Sausage was very bland! Liked The Crust. Overall we were not impressed. Probably first and last time. We love Pizza and have one every week. This will not be on our Return place.

4/1/25 I get lots of DoorDashes from here and decided to stop in to give them a try. The food is absolutely amazing! I had the breaded mushrooms and a pepperoni pizza. Absolutely the best pizza I’ve found anywhere in central Ohio! Affordable as well! The mushrooms were fantastic, except a couple of the larger ones were cold in the center. Not a huge fan of square cut pizza either but it doesn’t matter. I’ll definitely be back for the food. The staff is always super nice and I love their unique decor. You have to stop in! 4/10/25 Came back in for dinner, had fried green beans and the Veal Parm dine in special. Had their new waitress, Mandy. Super sweet and very charismatic. She’s doing a fantastic job! The best wait staff I’ve had in a long time anywhere. The food was absolutely perfect! D

I don’t often go to places without pizza in the name to get pizza, but Minico’s may have changed that. I ordered the Italian sub and a cheese pizza with roasted peppers. The first thing I noticed was the golden crisp of both of the doughs, with the gentlest crack with every mouthwatering bite. Once I got through the breading, the flavor of the ingredients whisked me away to the farms they came from. I could taste the fresh tomatoes with every bite of the pizza and each spice in the meat of the sub. The staff was very nice and someone came out of the kitchen to help me when he noticed the person at the register was occupied. The inside of the restaurant also had a very cozy atmosphere. One thing that I must comment on is that I originally wanted a cheese pizza but they are priced as cheese

Minico’s is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel genuinely welcome. Everyone was friendly, attentive, and clearly cared about making our experience great. They checked in at just the right times and were happy to answer questions or make recommendations with a smile. The warm, welcoming atmosphere really sets Minico’s apart, and it’s the kind of place that makes you want to come back not just for the food, but for the people. Highly recommend!

Have driven by for years, and finally was able to stop in! WOW!! This is worth it!! The nice crispy crust, cup pepperonis, and crumble sausage made the perfect combination. Not sure if the subtle hint of spice comes from the pepperoni or the sausage but it was just the right amount to not be overwhelming. Order was ready when the online portal said it would be, which is great on a busy Saturday night. Staff were very quick, efficient, and very friendly. 200/10 recommend, can’t wait to go back!