Middletown Valley Pizzeria

Might be the best pizza in Middletown. Got the carne and a cheese and both were delicious. They had just opened and were a little over whelmed by the number of orders. So, they could use more staff on a Saturday night. Never the less, the guy brought the pizzas out of the kitchen and apologized right away for the wait. Will be back.

Wonderful place! The staff is so, so nice. I went in to pick up my order and their system was acting up, so instead of making me wait for them to fix it they just comped my pizza. Which was totally delicious! My partner is vegan so he gets his with no cheese which they accommodated no problem. I will definitely be back! 10/10 experience

Pleasantly surprised! We haven’t been in since the new owners took over (we haven’t been in probably 8 years); and it’s great. Pizza is solid; but the Fried Ravioli was so good. Glad to have a good local pizza spot!

You should look into getting a different delivery app. Ordered twice and had issues both times, food is good, but didnt even get the pizza the second time, a waste of both of our time

Took my kids to dine in and had delicious mozzarella sticks and some really good pizza. The waiter was really nice and the owner even came out to greet us. Will be back.