Michaelangelo's Pizza

Excellent, New York style pizza! This was our second trip to Emerald Isle and we decided to stay close to the condo for dinner and stopped in Michaelangelo’s. They had pizza by the slice that the kids loved, one wanted cheese and both pepperoni. The wife and I wanted pepperoni and sausage. The 14” was way more than enough for us to the point that we took it back to the condo and had it for lunch the following day! They were pretty busy but they were all moving. The pizza was absolutely amazing! After experiencing a good bit of NY pizza in NYC and later in Charlotte NC, this one is just as awesome! I’d like the NY style pizza don’t miss out on this!

So friendly! Very clean! I always like when you can see your food being prepared & know it’s handled safely. The calzones are easily 2 meals or can be shared. The crust is light & crispy & the ricotta-to-mozzarella ratio perfect. They have a delicious lemoncello mascarpone cake that is a nice balance of sweet & tangy.

Open in the off season. We enjoyed a large pizza carry out both freshly made for dinner and cold for breakfast. Proper NY style slice. Extra point for incorporating the price of standard toppings into the whole pizza price.

Came in at 7:45 ordered two slices of pepperoni sausage extra cheese when I got the slices. There was hardly any extra cheese on the slices and they ran out of tea at 8 o’clock sweet tea. I asked them for more and they said they weren’t gonna make any more. They closed at 9.

Got it to go but seemed like your spitting image of a beach pizza spot. With that being said if you’re going for an idea of authentic Italian head to Italy because Olive Garden isn’t either. Slices are the way to go, good variety and the more toppings the more flop, so we got 4 slices well done and they were 🔥! For out of towners or overseas; this is not Chicago style, Detroit Style or you local chain. It’s NY Style and it truly was, thin, large slices that in New York fashion you can fold in half and eat. We snagged 2 supremes a cheese and a sausage/pepp was just under 20.00. Want to feed the family on a budget after you paid 400 plus a night, this will do the trick!