Mellow Mushroom Sandy Springs

Excellent food and experience - my favorite pizza in the world. I met a buddy for lunch today and decided to order something different since we ate pizza on Saturday. I went with the cheese & steak sandwich thinking it would be like a Philly cheesesteak but it wasn’t. It seemed to be more of a patty vs shaved steak so I asked our server about and the fun began. The GM (Matt) came by and we ended up having a great conversation about many things and he insisted I try their new burger while I insisted I was fine with what I got but wanted to make sure I hadn’t misread the menu. Long story short - it’s not shaved steak and the new burger was delicious. 😊 I truly appreciate Matt taking the time to come by and chat. I had no intention of sending anything back or complaining so he took and oka

Excellent Management Response Corrects Initial Mistake (Updated Review) Original Rating: 1/5 Stars Revised Rating: 6/5 Stars I originally posted a 1-star review detailing a frustrating experience where my Holy Shiitake pizza was delivered without the crucial garlic aoli drizzle. This required me to drive back to the store and the staff at the counter was unhelpful and offered no apology or compensation, leaving my entire $50 order to get cold. The store owner, Matt, personally called me to address the issue. I was extremely impressed by his approach. He was highly professional, taking full accountability for the mistakes made by the kitchen and the counter staff. He went above and beyond to make things right-- made me feel completely heard and understood with my experience. The owner'

I’ve loved Mellow Mushroom for years and it’s hands down my all-time favorite pizza spot, but the Mellow Mushroom Sandy Springs location truly stands out above the rest. One thing I really appreciate is the consistency and care in how the pizza is made here. At some locations, the crust can be overly wide with sparse toppings, or the slices are too unevenly cut. That’s not the case at this location. When you open the pizza box, everything looks beautifully made and thoughtfully presented and that satisfaction absolutely carries through to the taste. There’s something special about their dough here too: perfectly chewy on the inside, crisp on the outside, with a rich, deep flavor that just feels right. My go-to pizzas are the Super Pepp and Holy Shiitake, and they never disappoint. They a

Taylor was my server. I generally take out, but chose to dine in on Saturday. I'm a slow eater, was not hurried along or anything. Taylor was attentive & I had no wait for a drink, refill & my order was received in a timely manner. Eric (sp?) was thoughtful & greeted me warmly. I frequently visit this establishment semi-regularly & have gotten to know many of the servers, cooks & additional staff. I am fine with anyone servicing me - the staff seems like it's a fun place to work (outwardly anyway - I know it's still work). Food is top notch with a variety of options to select from. Cloud 9 wings are the bom - Pizza is one of the best pizza's in all of Atlanta (imo) & I'm looking forward to trying the 'delicious looking' smash burger. I have never had anything off the menu that I thought wa

Great pizza! Enjoyed the atmosphere and had good service.