McCools Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Love this place! Jaclilyn decorates the cakes so well and she did an awesome job converting a premade cake into a ghost spider color scheme for my daughter’s birthday! Highly recommend!

Service was great! Staff are friendly and attentive. However I was very disappointed that they don’t make any of their ice cream! It’s all Hershey’s brand. I guess if you like the endless options, go for it! But if you’re looking for an authentic ice cream shop, this ain’t it.

I Needed a last minute ice cream cake for my husband's birthday. I left work and did not know where to go and saw a huge amount of people sitting outside of this ice cream shop. I went in so frantic and I saw the manager, he saw me, and he completely just dropped everything and helped me right away. Because I told him that I had to get home quickly. He even added Happy Birthday to the cake even though he didn't have to. And I really, really appreciated it because there was a line. BONUS-- My husband loved the cake, and maybe 10 or 15 people asked me where I got it because it was so remarkable and fresh.

They have so many options it’s genuinely overwhelming, but the ice cream isn’t anything special, about as good as something you’d get at the grocery store—only more expensive. The staff is good and the interior is pretty cute. It’s definitely a good neighborhood spot but nothing fancy, perfect for a university town.

Awesome ice cream place! Pretty busy for a winter day in the 20s. Loved the Ice Cream Flight .. between my husband and I we were able to try 6 different Jr scoops of ice cream. Great for those that can't decide and love to taste different flavors.