Margherita Pizza Of Carroll Island

I don't know how to express my love for their sun dried cherry tomato chicken ranch pizza. It is just so good and I order a whole pizza everytime I go there. It is a MUST try. Their bread is just so good and appetizing. It fills up a whole family and you may even have left overs.

Absolutely the best pizza we've ever had. Our family can't help but order here every time we're in Middle River/White Marsh.

On Wednesday, May 7, 2025, I called at 5:48 PM to place a pickup order for a cheesesteak sub. Unfortunately, the condition in which I received the sub was unacceptable. Upon returning to the store to address the issue, I showed the staff the state of the order, but no one seemed to know how to respond or offer a resolution. I was met with confusion rather than assistance. As a paying customer, I believe in supporting local businesses, but I also expect a standard of quality and service. Regrettably, based on this experience, I do not plan to return.

I love coming here and sometimes take the 59 out to Carroll Island just for this restaurant. They sell by the slice so you don't have leftover pieces in a cardboard box to carry around. Very cozy place never had a bad bite here!

*Update: Came in for dine in service. Food was good. No complaints. Not really a sit down restaurant more so carryout. It was very warm inside. We enjoyed the food and the time together. Restaurant was clean and relaxed. I liked the coastal decorations and the plates. Just not my favorite place to dine in. I ordered the Margherita pasta with a caesar salad and shared it with my girls. The food is so good. Its a nice treat when your craving seafood pasta. The seafood is good quality and the sauce is delicious. My late sister loved this pasta so now its my homage to her. Will be ordering again.