Mama Mia's

This place is great!! I usually get my food to go but it's always amazing. The atmosphere when I'm watching and waiting my turn is real. They work hard and genuinely care about people. You can read the menu. I just moved to the area from Texas. I've been to allot of New places but this place has pulled me back in 5 or 6 times.

I love being able to get my favorite pizza locally! Crispy and thin NY pizza is lovely and I always order extra large pies. In the winter the soups keep me alive and well. Custom pizza and the best soup you will have. I suggest order all of the soups or at least take a sample, you are welcome!!

Stopped into Mama Mia’s in Geneseo for lunch with my two boys today, and we were so impressed! Service was quick and friendly, and the pizza was hands-down the best New York–style pizza we’ve had in a long time — crispy, cheesy, and delicious. Perfect spot for a casual, family-friendly meal. We’ll definitely be back! 🍕👏🏻

This is, in my opinion, the best pizza in Upstate NY. Geneseo is a college town and this place is right on Main Street. Sometimes it gets pretty busy but the prices are excellent and the pizza is outstanding. Typical New York, thin crust, pizza crispy crust on the bottom chewy throughout just the right amount of sauce and cheese.

I have come here since 1990 when it opened. I was attending SUNY-Geneseo and since I have graduated , had children who grew up eating mama mia, brought my niece and had brought my grandnieces ( they moved to Ohio and when they come to this area they insist that this is a must to get pizza from ), also my nephews have grown up coming here and now I have my grandson who love love loves the pizza. I hope Eddie never changes his formula !!! Is the best pizza in 1990 and still the best today