Mahoney's Atlantic Bar & Grill

We had a great dinner here. This is a nice place with a casual but nice vibe to it. It was busy when we arrived, but the service was attentive and the pace was very good; not rushed but not slow. The oysters were exceptional. The mains were also good. The steamed Atlantic bowl was excellent and the portion was huge. The lobster was good. Everyone seemed happy with their choices. The cocktails were excellent. Overall it was a nice evening but the pricing makes it more of a special occasion place than a local hangout place.

An enjoyable surprise! Our son has been very pleased every time they've dined here! Food was excellent! Service from Debbie was great as were her recommendations! Deserts were outstanding! This should be everyone's must try dine list when visiting Orleans/Brewster area! 👍👍👍

Absolutely love this place!! Amazing food!!! The tuna sashimi was amazing. Must try the combo meat skewers. The shrimp is so buttery and delicious. The pan roasted lobster was so tasty and cooked perfectly. The Atlantic Steamer bowl. Was a bowl full of amazing steamy goodness. We also added a lobster to it and it was soooo good. The chicken Caesar salad was very good and the chicken cooked perfectly. The NY strip steak was cooked to perfection.

Very friendly waitress named Deborah. Loud restaurant. Our scallop dinners were good. The mushroom risotto a bit undercooked. Clam chowder tasted great. Never had a blueberry white chocolate bread pudding. That was delicious and enjoyed by both of us! The tea service was elegant with a pot and cup in one.

Worth every penny. Showed up right before the big dinner rush. There were a couple people ahead of us though so we jumped on the list and grabbed margaritas from the bar (note the bar is wait to be seated so you need to tell the bartender if you want a seat at the bar - not your typical grab a chair if its available situation. Really good margaritas! Only snafu of the night, there are no buzzers or "texts when your table is ready" for people on the wait list. We waited for almost an hour once I realized there were people getting seated that came in after us. Went to check in with the host and "missing" was written next to our name even though we were two chairs down at the bar. Once that issue was resolved and we were seated immediately, the rest of the night was perfect. A lovely bottle o