Maguire's Bayfront Restaurant

Came here for lunch on a weekday. There was no wait and plenty of seating available on the outdoor area. It is very nice to sit outside and view the bay. This is my first visit for a meal in a few years. I remember the portion sizes being quite small, but today the portions for each dish were extremely generous! The food was also very delicious and the ingredients were fresh. Service was polite and prompt. To my surprise, the burger was served with a slice of watermelon! Refreshing!

Some friends, my wife, and I recently had lunch at Maguire's Bayfront Restaurant in Ocean Beach. The food was fresh and delicious, and the cocktails were excellent. I highly recommend trying Bubba’s Five Rum Punch. It’s a standout drink. If you stop at the bar, be sure to see Erik. He’ll take great care of you and makes incredible cocktails. One of the best parts of dining at Maguire’s is sitting in the back, where you can enjoy a stunning view of the Great South Bay. I definitely recommend Maguire’s Bayfront Restaurant if you’re planning a trip to Fire Island.

Feel like Fire Island has a lot of great food options but if you’re looking for THE dinner spot, this is it. It feels more like a sit down dinner than some of the other places on the coast, and you have such a great view of the water, sunset, etc. Food was pretty good and portions were much larger than I expected. Given that it’s Fire Island, prices are pretty much in line with that. The steak went above and beyond expectations though! Servers are great. Nice drinks menu. And the bread was so good, got multiple baskets and loved every single bite. Would definitely recommend if you’re in the area!

Warm and cozy atmosphere. Very friendly and welcoming place . Great food , fresh and super tasty. Our waiter was super nice and very friendly. He did an amazing job ! This place deserves more than 5 stars ! I'll give 10!

Great place to view sunset if you get outdoor seating! The sunset that day was beautiful, but unfortunately we were not able to get outdoor dining. Food is crazy overpriced and overall not worth it. We had the Pineapple Bowl, Thai chicken, Signature Salad, kids butter pasta, and kids hot dog. Pineapple bowl was in an actual pineapple which was pretty cool. The taste/flavor was not bad. Thai chicken was a bit dry. Salad was one of cheaper options (around $20 I believe) but the taste was a little dry. However, with added chicken (and only given a few pieces) it added another $10 to the salad… 😕 Crazy. Butter pasta was fine, the hot dog was burnt… Our kid couldn’t even eat it. On a small island, it’s expected to be overpriced, but overall the food was not that great. The view is spectacula