Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies

I have been a customer of mafia Pizza for a while now since they were established here in Monticello, and usually the food is great, although a little expensive, but this time around, it was very dissatisfactory. I ordered a extra large Pizza with all the trimmings and what I got was less than Pizza Hut quality? They skimmed on the toppings. The dough was undercooked and it was just not satisfying at all the time I got home. I was too tired to do anything about it. I tried to call back the next day. But because of the business hours, they were closed and I just pretty much gave up my fiancé, and I will not be going back here. After this experience, unless something is done.Because I cannot afford to go through this twice.Especially for the price

This place really got the spot! The wings came out steaming hot and they were big wings! I was really impressed with the quality of the wings. The skin was crispy as if they were baked and it was so good! I ordered a build your own pizza and I really enjoyed the pizza dough! It was cooked perfectly! I would eat here again! My wings and pizza were about $26 in total. If you pay in cash you get a 4% discount and if you pay with card a 4% service charge is added.

Great place, decent pricing and nice people.

Very cool little place. Very good pizza, decent wings, impressive salad bar. The line is kind've blurred between table service and counter service so it gets a bit confusing. Located in a very cool historic building. Unfortunately, this in combination with the pizza ovens makes it very HOT in the summer. No worse than eating on an outdoor patio. Maybe add some fans for that fifth star, but we will be back!

Mafia is a great blend of small town feel and big city flavor! They have good pizza and pretty good wings. Big fan of their Buffalo chicken pizza and the godfather! I don’t think you’ll be disappointed with anything you get at Mafia!