Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream

We enjoyed multiple flavors at locations in Vineyard Haven, Edgartown and Oak Bluffs during our week stay on the island. Staff are friendly and we enjoyed all the flavors we got to try. We thought the ice cream was very creamy, flavors were great, and mix-ins were plentiful. Not budget ice cream, but worth the price. Limited indoor seating at all the locations. Staff were always friendly.

Ice cream was good, shakes were ok but not thick. Price wasn’t too bad! Ordered a small mint Oreo with hot fudge and Oreo crumbles, husband ordered a vanilla shake.

Best açaí bowl we have ever had. You have to put hot fudge on it! The atmosphere is so fun and welcoming. The food looked very good and staff was nice.

Well they're definitely "mad". We were ignored and hardly served, ice cream was meh.

Ice cream was great, but have you ever had bad ice cream? Facility was clean, staff was helpful and friendly and the location was easy. Nice assortment of flavors!