Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream

Probably some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. It’s the legit real deal. Heavy, thick, creamy. Loved it!

Classic New England ice cream shop, lots of interesting flavors (both classic and unique), and plenty of space to queue and eat. The speed of service was lacking and they could add a few more staff members on shift at minimal cost to the business compared to how much additional throughput they'd have.

We strolled in on a Friday in October. The nice man behind the counter handled our party of six children so patiently. (Big decisions to be made, you understand.) Thank you! Absolutely delicious. Get the blueberry!

They had a very delicious and diverse selection of dairy-free options for ice cream! We tried all of them and thoroughly enjoyed each one. The flavor of the week, which featured raspberry, was my favorite.

Mad Martha's Ice Cream on Martha's Vineyard is a nostalgic treasure trove of delightful frozen treats. With a wide array of flavors that range from classic to inventive, there's something to satisfy every palate. Their commitment to using local products in their ice creams truly sets them apart, adding an authentic touch to each scoop. Personally, my heart belongs to the Chilmark Coffee flavor - a robust and creamy indulgence that perfectly captures the essence of Martha's Vineyard. What makes Mad Martha's even more special is their strong community focus. With locations in three different towns on the island, they've become an integral part of the Vineyard vacation experience. The bustling atmosphere and cheerful staff exude a welcoming vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. It's ev