Lilly's Steaks & Cocktails

Choosing this restaurant for my birthday dinner was a no brainer. It's a steak and cocktails rest. , must be good right? However, I thought I was gonna have a good birthday dinner with friends. Here is my experience. First, Waitress wasn't trained enough to ask guest their prefered water, so we asked her some tap. Tap water was disgusting( sorry for the word), never have I ever tasted tap water like it. Second, How is the sanitizer in the pump bottle next to salt and pepper on the table? Think of kids or old people would think it's a condiments. Chemicals and food should not be on the same place. It's chemical contamination! Third, I'm on my thirties and can clearly see, but this restaurant has the dimmest lighting ever. Fourth, This restaurant is expensive and we know this beforehand.

My parents and I had a great dining experience here. Nicole was great. She was super friendly and just made the whole experience better. We will be returning soon.

Honeymoon dinner! Everything was absolutely delicious! The women working here are so kind and attentive! Cocktails are a bit pricey but overall the meal was not that bad! The 42oz porterhouse for two was totally worth it! At $110.00 I believe you got enough food for the price!

Lilly’s Steakhouse in Windham, New York, is one of my favorite spots in the state. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, with a warm, rustic charm that makes you want to stay awhile. The food is consistently exceptional from tender steaks to comforting classics like shepherd’s pie and the service is always kind and attentive. Whether it’s quiet or fully booked, I’ve never waited long. Parking is easy, and the occasional hello from the owner adds a personal touch. I highly suggest Lily’s especially if you have a large party.

I had to get a take-out order because I couldn't bring my dog to dine in with me which I understand that. The con part of taking out was the food won't be good as you eat at the restaurant. If something wrong with the food and you don't have any access or cooking wear to fix it yourself, you will have to accept it or just throw it away. My husband and I were blessed enough to be able to bring it to our place and eat at the hotel cafe. We ordered..... - Porterhouse: looked good from outside. we told the restaurant to make it medium but the steak still more rare so the rest of rare part, we gave it to our dog, and he loved it. 7/10 - Lilly’s Beef Wellington: Prime 8oz Filet Mignon with wild mushroom in red wine glaze. I rarely see mushroom inside the wrap. Beef was good and perfectly cooke