Keys Fresh Seafood Market

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We partner with this seafood company exclusively for a reason, their quality is on another level. Working with clients from around the world they expect very high level cuisine when they hire us for their private chef events. Keys shrimp has this incredible, almost crab-like texture that feels unreal, and the tuna is consistently rich, clean, and absolutely delicious. The Faroe Island salmon is like butter, just melts. Every product we get from them is top tier. We use their snapper and grouper for ceviche and sashimi, and it’s always pristine, fresh, and reliable. As chefs, consistency matters and they deliver every single time. Easily the best seafood partner we’ve ever worked with. You will not be disappointed. Not to mention Michele always takes care of us and provides the

I recently ordered stone crab claws from this website, and the experience exceeded my expectations. The claws arrived fresh, perfectly packed, and tasted absolutely incredible — sweet, tender, and exactly what you hope for with high-quality stone crab. What really stood out was the mustard sauce. It was rich, flavorful, and complemented the crab perfectly without overpowering it. You can tell it was made with care and the right balance of ingredients. Overall, everything from the ordering process to the quality of the product was excellent. I would definitely order again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for authentic, delicious stone crab delivered to their door.

The shrimp, stone crab, and fish were good but BEWARE that they trick you with the pricing!! When you place an order online with a “sale” or “discount” code, the price is higher online than in the store, so you end up paying the regular price you would get in the store anyway. We had placed an order a few days early, during a “sale,” and went to pick it up at the allotted time we specified online…and guess what? It wasn’t ready. I’m fine waiting, but why make us select a time that we rushed to arrive at? Don’t set that precedent/request if you cannot meet it. And when we asked why the price was so much lower on their board in the store than what was online, the kid looked like he got caught with his hand in the cookie jar and ran to the back. When he came out he had no explanation as to

Want fresh right off the boat seafood? This is the spot! Restaurant + Seafood Market absolutely can’t beat it. Old school Key West at its finest with incredible seafood. The market was filled up with fresh cut fish, lobster, shrimp, seafood salads of all kinds and multiple other items. Luckily we had an empty cooler in the car because we stacked up heavy on this visit. Not only is this a place for premium quality fresh seafood but it is an experience to enjoy as well. Right on the water with live lobsters and marina is loaded with fish, sharks, and more!

Delivered as expected!! Ordered colossal stone crabs and lobster tails, arrived cold and fresh just as described on site. What a pleasure to deal with a company who understands customer satisfaction. Would definitely order again!