Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Go anywhere but here. Ordered take out my first time. Baked penne and added Italian sausage to it. Guess what’s missing!! The sausage we paid extra for! Big shocker 🙄😒 the sauce is canned garbage. I wanted the Alfredo but if gave me no option in online ordering to get it without the yucky chicken plus charged an additional $4 for the chicken. The garlic cheese bread is laughable. The cheese is only in the center not the edges. Definitely won’t be back to this dumpster. In fact I want a refund. I could’ve boiled pasta, opened a cheap jar of sauce and added minimal cheese and had a cheaper faster meal. Thanks for nothing. I hate jefferson pizza is gone. Was way way better than this place. This is exactly why I’m hesitant to spend money at places that demand tips for online pick up orders be

What a great Italian joint for Jefferson!!! The place was packed and all the dishes we saw looked fantastic! We thoroughly enjoyed sharing cheese sticks as an appy followed by my cousin enjoying his Spaghetti & Meatballs with a Caesar Salad and my friend and I enjoyed a Hawaiian Flatbread with Hot Honey drizzled on top. I was also impressed with my Smoked Old Fashioned! We will be back!!! Highly recommend. Our server was April and she was absolutely lovely!

My husband and I came here with our 3 children. We waited over an hour. Finally got our food all we ordered was a cheese/pepperoni and a ham and cheese pizza. They brought it out to us uncut! We asked for them to cut both pizzas as they were too hot for us to cut them. They said they couldn't and would bring us steak knives cause we touched it. I asked if they could just come cut it and then the tool they used can be washed they said no. Then we found a hair on our pizza so at least the kids got to eat after waiting forever. But it was pointless for us. This isn't the first time we have had a problem here we were giving it a 2nd try but now we absolutely will not be be coming back!!! My Husband and I and very upset! I didnt know I needed to being my own pizza cutter in my purse to eat pizz

My family was wanting an authentic NY style pizza and I recommended we give this place a try because I’ve driven by there a few times. Parking is tricky. Don’t park right out front because you might be stuck for a while. The service was friendly and helpful and the large meat lovers pizza was a hit! Slices were huge and they definitely loaded on the toppings. The interior was clean and spacious with really great decor. Will definitely be returning.

Did lunch and was clean and pleasant atmosphere. Ordered 6 wings hot flavor. Friend ordered a Buffalo chicken wrap. Wings were cooked perfect but the needed more sauce. Mike was our server and he did a phenomenal job!!! Thought it was a bit pricey for the amount of food you get. Online prices do not match this location. Wings with no drink was $9.62 Buffalo chicken wrap served with water $12.