Joe's New York Pizza

Moved in down the street and decided to try out this place. Have now come back six times and used their takeout Love their pizza. The 14 inch medium pizza is perfect for two people. The mozzarella sticks were delicious and the small garden salad is actually quite large. The lemon cake is outstanding. They also have a pizza buffet, but I have not tried that yet. For lunch, we’ve had the godfather sub which was very tasty. They have a large menu with lots of options from appetizers, salad, pizza, entrées, and calzones. Service has been outstanding here. Quick to come take your order and to follow up frequently to make sure you have everything you need. Trinity, Lauren and Lexi are some of the excellent wait staff here. There is indoor seating, outdoor seating and a bar. Good selectio

I can’t tell you how frustrating our experience was this evening. We got to the restaurant, waited for 2 families to check out, watched the people in front of us be seated, and then were told they couldn’t set us for 15minutes because the staff would get confused because they had too many phone orders. They had 4 tables seated with patrons. Needless to say we left and went to Mellow Mushroom. They sat us right away in a full restaurant and didn’t get confused about any part of our order.

Really enjoyed the atmosphere! The owners were absolutely amazing and so was the staff. The pizza is top notch and the bourbon prices are very fair. I will definitely be back to Joes!

An hour and a half for a single to-go pie and salad is mind-boggling. That should not be the standard. I like your sign at the front “fresh to order, we are not fast food.”… You know when there is ANY kind of disclaimer, it’s time to buckle up. How about you put a nice little pop-up online that says that before the customer orders? …. I think you’re resting on that “not fast food” sentiment a little too much….. It’s like they were insulted that I asked about it after an hour and some change. Please, if you don’t want to serve to-go orders or they’re an inconvenience then just kindly don’t offer that service. there are definitely diners that came in after me, sat down and were served food before I was given my to go order. So to give you an idea, people that just walked in off the street w

We arrived to Joes at 6:40pm on February 20,2026. Ordered our food .. at 8:05 pm our food arrived.. No silverware was given to us..we had to ask for it… My pizza was wrong. The fettuccini Alfredo with broccoli was half cooked with the noodles being hard. She couldn’t eat what I paid $17.00 for. I received excuse after excuse for this. We were not the only customers who waited over 1 hour and a half for food. We were told that they had a lot of to go orders and parties. You do not prioritize to go orders over customers who have been seated and are waiting on food. I normally do not place reviews but this is ridiculous. Poor management in every aspect . This place has always been a great place to come and eat a pizza but I will not be back until management figures out how to run a restaur