Joe’s Coney Island

I ordered from here for the first time Monday 2/23/26 around 1:30a.m. I was so excited to have a late night coney island in my area. I ordered my bacon well done but this is unacceptable and inedible! Some of the hashbrowns were burnt as well. The toast was a bit stale. The parts that were edible were good. It was too late to call and return as aI had work on the morning. Granted he appeared to be working alone, was pleasant but to send this with a customer is deceitful! You can't miss this! I was waiting patiently inside. It would have taken a few minutes to make the bacon again. Will not patronize again especially since this is how they handle their customer's food, time and money!

I was really craving a brownie sundae, so I ordered one, but it turned out to be quite disappointing. The packaging was done very poorly, the whipped cream had melted and mixed with the ice cream, and the brownie didn’t taste fresh at all. Definitely not what I expected.

I ordered a chicken finger wrap which I didn’t realize until halfway through eating that the lettuce was completely wilted and brown! Also in one of my bites of the wrap, I crunched something hard and discovered an orange piece of plastic (which was IN MY MOUTH) just disgusting ! I threw it away immediately. Absolutely unacceptable.

Nice atmosphere and great service. Food very good just missing a 5 rating. I've heard from others it's hit or miss depending on the dish. Clean and plenty of parking

Overall, a really good place to eat. It's roomy with a bunch of seating. The staff was friendly and attentive. There is an amazing amount of variety on the menu. Food was pretty good and prices are great. The pita on my gyro was fresh and really good, but ther was a bit too much tzatziki sauce for me. The fries were really good and perfectly cooked. My wife reports that the fish was good as well. Great place for a family meal, especially for large groups. Can't wait to visit again.