Jimmy's Apizza

Wow! My first experience with New Haven style and I can see why Portnoy loves it. Great crust, little flop, sauce was spot on. He only gave them an 8.1 (which is solid for him), I said they were an 8.2. Service was superb, couldn't ask for better service. The French Onion Soup was absolutely delicious. We also had the garlic knots, which were the best I've had. The garlic sauce and marinara mingled a sweet dance on my taste buds, get them, you won't be disappointed. The only thing I regret is I didn't get a hoodie to take home, maybe they will reach out and let me know how I can get one 😁 DO NOT pass on Jimmy's Apizza.

The service was excellent from start to finish—every staff member was friendly, welcoming, and genuinely happy to be there. You can tell they really care about their customers. The food came out hot, fresh, and delicious, and the portions were huge—definitely great value for the price. The pizza had that perfect balance of flavor and crispness, and everything we tried tasted homemade and authentic.

I went for a lunch and ordered a small Cheese and Sausage pizza, I didn't know what to expect but was extremely happy. The pizza tasted Fresh and delicious. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone.

Wow, after eating at Jimmy's tonight I just had to say something. The food was sooooo good!. The large ceaser salad was enough for 3 people with leftovers. My husband had 2 meatballs and could only finish one. I had the garlic parm wings which were the BEST EVER!! I've never had any better. the wings were crisp, warm, and with enough oil for a smooth mouth feel. I can't wait to go back!! It's a simple place but the employees and customers are the nicest, kindest people anywhere. Try Jimmy's Apizza in Milford. Went back again tonight, just as good as last time. Food great, wings crispy and delicious, staff very polite and attentive and customers also very kind and helpful. just a great place.

Definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! We stopped by on our way through and were pleasantly surprised. We ordered three different kinds — Danielle, Brittany, and Pepperoni — and each one was perfect. The dough was both soft and crunchy, the tomato sauce was packed with flavor, and the spiciness of the buffalo chicken was just right. Highly recommended!