Jay Street Subs

Where to start? This is a humble little shop on the corner of State & Jay that makes the most delicious subs, and offers the most delicious soups. It doesn’t make sense how these folks take simple ingredients and turn them into something wonderful - something many competitors lack. On top of their wonderful food, their prices are beyond fair and the staff is incredible. You can tell that each customer is so much more than that to them, their love and dedication shines through. Highly recommend next time you’re looking for a lunch spot!

Just went and got lunch here yesterday and today. The same super nice woman made both of my subs and they have been so damn good. Joked with her about how I’ll be food coma trying to finish this second one. She’s awesome. Couldn’t really ask for more. Solid damn sub shop. 5 stars all day. I had to come edit my review. These are the sweetest people on earth. I have an almost 100 pound dog named Tiva I bring with me when I come to get subs. They feed her, love on her and damn near want to take her home. This place and the people in it are truly amazing. No one else can make me a 5 star sub and then tackle a Cane Corso like it’s a 5 pound dog puppy. I love this sub shop!

I love this sub shop! I stop by each week (sometimes twice) to grab a quick lunch and my food is always ready and delicious. Not to mention how incredibly nice all the people that work there are! The subs are yummy, they have some of the best prices in the area, you can order online, and they have punch card rewards! What's not to love! Stop by for a tasty sub at a great price from the nicest people!

Ordered here for a quick Grubhub lunch. My husband ordered the Buffalo chicken sub and I got a spicy Italian. The flavor was what you’d expect but wow! I could have went to Subway and received more meat and cheese on my sub. One spread out layer of each meat and they split the cheese slices to stretch the length of the bread. The chicken sub seemed to have more to it but it was definitely a little dry. I’ll spend the extra buck and drive to go to Pellegrinos or just head to subway next time.

This is a hidden hole in the wall. The staff are super cool. The subs we had were delicious. They got our order wrong, but all the wrongness was still tasty. There wasn’t a shred of lettuce leftover because the entire platter got devoured. I don’t believe they deliver. If they do, then it’s only when they are open. I gave one less star because they have oddly difficult hours. You cannot go there after work and get any food. Can’t use them for you Saturday or Sunday cook outs unless you was day old subs. I would have been ordered from them multiple times already but could not because of the reasons I stated above. Their prices are very affordable and well staffed to get you in and out of the door immediately.