Jay Street Bistro

Came for breakfast on a Sunday morning. It was delightful busy, but we were able to get a table without a wait. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Service was just a tad slow, but it was rather busy, and the staff did a great job working together and keeping everything moving. The Cornbread French Toast was wonderful, will definitely order that again the next time I'm in town. The iced mocha latte was served in very cute glassware, and was refreshing on a humid summer morning. We'll definitely be back.

Popped in for a late lunch/early dinner on a Saturday afternoon and we had no problem getting a table inside with good air conditioning on a hot late spring day. We had a friendly and efficient waiter. Our appetizers which we shared, the tuna tartare, and the chicken quesadilla, were both excellent. Two of us had the cheeseburger and we both asked for it to be done medium rare and unfortunately they came out well done. Disappointing. We were all too hungry too complain and/or send them back so we ate them as they were delivered. One person had the corn beef Reuben, which he enjoyed. Forgot to take pictures of the menu or the interior of the restaurant, but they did have a list of milkshakes which were very tempting, but we were too full to indulge.

I recently stopped by Jay Street Bistro in Katonah for a quick bite and ordered the Lentil Bowl Salad. Unfortunately, I was quite disappointed with the dish. The overwhelming amount of sunflower seeds and dry lentils made it feel more like bird food than a satisfying meal. Although the server offered additional dressing, the tahini-based option provided was excessively thick and did little to improve the salad’s dryness. To enhance this dish, I suggest better balancing the ingredients, perhaps by mixing them more evenly and incorporating juicy elements like tomatoes. At $17, the salad felt overpriced, especially considering I could have purchased a bag of bird food for the same price.

One of my favorite places ever. That cornbread French toast with their syrup is amazing. Their French fries are thin and salty. The environment, the town it’s in, the food, everything is so worth going

Stopped by for breakfast before a big hike. This is one of the few places open at 8am in the area. Good menu options, decent prices, & attentive service. Only item I wish was better was their coffee.