Italian Village Pizza

Italian Village Pizza is a true neighborhood gem in Madison. Located right on Main Street, this spot delivers exactly what you want from a classic Italian pizzeria—consistently great food, generous portions, and friendly service. The pizza is always fresh with a perfectly crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and quality toppings. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie, everything comes out hot and satisfying. Their menu goes beyond pizza too—pastas, heroes, and classic Italian comfort dishes are all solid choices. What really stands out is the welcoming, old-school vibe and how reliable they are. It’s the kind of place you keep coming back to because you know you’ll never be disappointed. If you’re in Madison and craving classic Italian pizza done right, Italian Village

Anywhere else in the world this would be a great pizzeria, but in this area it’s just ok. I have been getting slices from IVP since the mid-80’s and it was always 5 star, really excellent. It changed a couple years ago and it’s only ok now. As others have mentioned, the pizza is very oily, much more so than other NJ pizzerias. I get pepperoni slices at other places and they are never as greasy as they are here. The crust is ok, but something makes their slices greasy/oily. In summary, this once glorious pizzeria (for close to 40 years) is now a second tier pizzeria. The slices are just ok.

The food was good. Order at counter they bring to you. Very nice staff. My husband found place. Yes I would go back. Big portions had to take home.

buffalo chicken wings are the best i've had in years. They were crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and the buffalo sauce was just right, not too spicy, not too mild. I could've eaten a whole bucket them. Definitely going back for more!

Had the opportunity to stop here for the Pizza Hunters App and was surprised by a very good slice of pizza. Walked through the door and the people greeted me and were very nice. This is always a great start to a pizza experience. Had a slice that was warm, though should have had it heated up because the sauce was very, very good. A great homemade sauce that hits with every bite. I was surprised by this place , but should not have been since they have been in business so long. Great Job.