Italian Pie

We ordered garlic knots (8 or 12-piece) They were PHENOMENAL. They’re the size of Hawaiian rolls, not pretzel garlic knots, so they are good for a group of people and not so much for a couple. It was served with the best marinara sauce I’ve ever had in my life! We also ordered a medium BBQ Brisket Pie, which was exceptional, but it was the size of a large pizza (and the price of one as well). If I had known how big the M pie was, I would have saved some money and gotten a small. If I would have know how extensive the prices were, I wouldn’t have eaten here to begin with. The dining area is crowded, but the tables and benches are great for large groups. It’s self-serve minus the fact that food is brought to the table. The bathrooms are dark, but generally clean and spacious. The menu was my

This restaurant is under a new brand and has new management. It is classic New York style pizza and the garlic knots are delicious. They have a variety of other options like salads, wings, pasta, calzones and lasagna. Everything that we have tried is pretty tasty. Pro tip: if you have a picky pizza eater they serve slices all the time which can be a great option and they have a variety of adult beverages as well. Overall, a great experience for classic pizza in town.

DELICIOUS pizza! So super happy we finally have a good pizza near us. Their subs are just as good! Everything taste homemade if not close to it. I just wish they had a bit better fries but there's plenty more appetizers to choose from. They have great prices for the size as well!

Five stars for a much-needed addition to downtown Winder! As a former New Yorker, I know good pizza and this place delivers. The shop is clean, the food is genuinely well-made, and the picnic-table seating adds a casual charm that fits the community. I was genuinely sad when the former business closed, but I’m glad to see a new local spot stepping in and doing it right. Wishing them every success. Highly recommend stopping in and supporting this new business.

Absolutely loved everything about this place! It’s about time downtown Winder got a true taste of great Italian pizza. I stopped in on their second day of opening and was immediately impressed. The restaurant is spotless, well put together, and the staff is incredibly friendly and professional. I even had the pleasure of meeting the owner — very polite, engaging, and genuinely passionate about what they’re building here. One of the first things that caught my attention was the size and variety of their menu, especially considering how affordable everything is. Their lunch specials are unbeatable (see photo). My wife and I were able to share the two-slice-and-a-drink combo because the slices were huge and loaded with toppings. I wish I had a picture of my slice, but it looked so good I co