Indian Lake Pizza and Subs

I live in the Columbus Ohio area and drive over an hour to this restaurant because of the nostalgia of how good the pizza is. We haven’t been there since they changed the name from cassanos to Indian lake pizza. We were very disappointed. The whole pizza has changed. Now they are huge slices and different crust! Very sad because we were looking forward to the pizza the most!! We also had garlic bread with cheese which was fire. The service was great. Just miss the old pizza and the small crispy slices. If you’re looking for nostalgic cassanos it sadly isn’t it anymore. Hopefully they can make it how it used to be!

It used to be Cassano's Pizza King and we used to stop and get a pizza on our way home to CBus for the last 35 years. I'm very sad to say Indian lake Pizza is NOT Cassano's and we will no longer be stopping to get one on our way home to CBus. We were all so so disappointed when we tried the pizza. Different crust, different sauce, different pepperoni. Sign on the building said "Cassano's". I should have listened when they answered the phone but I was so happy to be ordering our favorite pizza. Did they all get sold or are there still Cassano's Pizza King still out there???

Service was terrible. Waitress was not friendly or attentive, no smiles or positive energy. The food was not good. Breadsticks had no seasoning other than being covered in flour and were served with what tasted exactly like Ragu spaghetti sauce, yuk! The pizza came out and looked completely RED - had probably 1 1/2 CUPS sauce on one pizza. Waitress asked if everything was ok, I politely told her the pizza had far too much sauce, she smirked and said sorry. She never asked anyone for refills, we had to ask for them. The atmosphere was not pleasant, no music, just sitting in tiny booths in silence when dining. We didn’t realize the place was no longer Cassanos, man did we make a mistake stopping there to eat. Absolutely disgusting!!! I do not recommend this place.

Just moved to the area and I am trying all the different pizza shops around. All have been awesome until I got to Indian Lake Pizza and Subs. Called in to be met with an obvious disgruntled employee who sounded pissed on the phone. I told her that I would like to place an order for pickup and she said: "WHAT DO YOU WANT!" I replied that I actually did not need anything and ended the call. That was my first and last impression. I will never eat here. Good luck

The food is great, but forget about placing an order with them on a Friday or Saturday night. Won’t answer their phones, after several attempts to call, and this has been a repeat issue. I love supporting local, but it’s hard to not go to a chain pizza shop when the local business can’t answer their phone and is the only way to place an order.