Hungry Buffalo

Got here on a weeknight about 6pm and it was dead. That might’ve been a clue (it is off season for Hocking Hills), but it filled up with customers as we ate. I love soft pretzels with a draft beer, but I was dismayed that they had a garlic butter coating. My wife thought it was amazing, and complimented the queso well-which, to my surprise, it did! The buffalo chili was good as well. She got the chicken Philly, which was good and huge. We took it back to the cabin and had plenty for dinner the next night. She got a large portion of fries, and a pretty good Mac & cheese. I was intrigued by the meatloaf; and yes, the “red sauce” is ketchup. Not bad though-something you’d make at home for dinner. Service was good, beer was cold. Overall, a nice place I’d eat at again.

We thought food was pretty good. Got the sampler appetizer platter, boneless wings, and a side Cesar salad. All was good and average fairly priced. We felt the Salad was huge for a side salad! Very good. Also got a few cocktails that were great! The Rocky Mtn and blood moon were the best. Enjoyed it all. Our waitress wasn’t the best, but will go again when in HH.

Delicious food and great staff. Unfortunately, we didn't get throw any axes, so thats just another excuse to go back :)

12/30/25 update: We've actually been here quite a few times. Our server today, Heath, was great. He made sure that we were well taken care of. I had the Buffalo Meatloaf and it was really good. My wife had her usual, the Monte Cristo, and loved it, as usual. We both went for the blackberry pie and were happy that we did.

Ax throwing was amazing!! They made us feel at home even though we were out of towners! Gift shop has nice ring selection we purchased and food was good.