Hocking Hills Bakery

Was visiting from Pittsburgh and am SO GLAD that Hocking Hills Bakery showed up when I searched the area for bakeries. Every single thing we ordered was magnificent: two types of cinnamon rolls, peach hand pie, chocolate peanut butter brownie, peanut butter pie, chocolate chip cookies, and garlic pull apart bread. Absolutely delicious across the board (my favs were the peach hand pie and peanut butter pie, my husband's was the cinnamon roll) and the owners were SO kind and helpful. I wish we lived closer so we could go there all the time. (They deserve better pictures than what I took, but I'm impatient and just wanted to eat!)

Recently met my family in Hocking Hills (we are spread out through the country) and we had two birthdays to celebrate. My grand daughters were over joyed with their Barbie cakes. Cakes were moist and dense and I think we had enough cake to feed the entire park! Their prices were very competitive compared to what I have paid in the past for a similar cake. I highly recommend them! But wait! It didn't stop there while in the store we also got to try some of their other pastries totally divine!

Never had anything from here that wasn't top notch delicious. They were even able to put a picture on a pumpkin pie! I needed a pumpkin pie with an eatable photo on it and they pulled it off and looked great for the birthday we were celebrating.

Hands down our favorite place to get fresh cookies and baked goods! The staff is super friendly and they actually remember who they’ve talked to on social media…they knew I was bringing my Mom in and we were definitely surprised they remembered. I recommend checking this shop out!!

Best cinnamon rolls I've ever had! So glad they participated in the 2025 annual Hocking Hills Food Cruise! Had to grab a cake pop for my little one.