Hometown Pizza

I've been a regular at Hometown Pizza for a while now, and every time I swing by I'm greeted with a quick, upbeat vibe that feels like a friendly catch-up. My go-to is the small chicken salad with bacon—no croutons, ranch dressing—and it's always fresh, tasty, and exactly how I ordered it. The staff never miss a beat; they get my order right and serve it promptly, which is a lifesaver when I'm short on time. I appreciate that they keep the menu simple enough to offer healthy options without sacrificing flavor. In short, Hometown Pizza consistently delivers a reliable, delicious meal that keeps me coming back.

Small little shop with big shop taste when u walk in it's like taking a step back into the 50's pizza shops the lady greets u with a heartfelt warmth like u back at Grandma's house. The pizza is phenomenal, the pizza sauce has a sweet but tangy sauce, they load it up with cheese, and it's great. Highly recommend checking this place out whenever your in Hicksville.

My family loves this place! The pizzas are fantasticand the staff is so very kind. My children and I are not local. We visit the area semi-frequently to see family and this is one of our favorite places to get take away from. Even my Dairy-Allergic child LOVED her pizza of just Crust, Sauce, Bell Peppers, and Black Olives.

It's an absolute joke that they let you order whatever you want just for you to get there and it's not available at all so you just dont get it. Like are you that greedy that you want money even if it means lying to customers that you have everything when you dont?! First time no onion rings now deepfryer not working like i assume that's very important information dont let someone order onion rings if you can't make it! It's an absolute joke and waste of money that i ordered hometown again especially since their food has a 50/50 chance of coming out cold or just sitting there for an unreasonable amount of time so it is cold. I can't believe im saying this but go to the McDonald's here at least there your food will be warm and they'll tell you when something is broken or missing like how th

If I'm craving a personal pizza, I will drive all the way from Indiana to Ohio to get hometown! It's always made fresh and delicious! My pregnant wife had a pregnancy craving for specifically Hometown Pizza and I didn't hesitate to make the drive to get it. I order from my house, and its ready to go by the time I get there and its always affordable! Honestly, the only the reason to ever go to Ohio.