Golden Guernsey Ice Cream

Charming ice cream shop with old timey ambiance. We stopped because of east on/off on I-88. They use Perry’s Ice Cream, which is just OK ice cream. The flavor variety was disappointing. We shared a large and wanted 3 balance flavors - vanilla based, chocolate based and a special flavor. Out of 37 listed flavors, only 3 are chocolate based. The only one we considered (don’t like raspberry or mint) was the dregs at the bottom, which we did not want (we asked if they pull out a new bucket - they declined; most places would scrap that out & put it at the top of a new bucket). There are lots of other interesting flavors though, many fruit or nut based. Portion size, average (not generous). Pro-tip, share a large ($5.50, 3 scoops ) and you can get 3 different flavors for 3 people to try (instea

The ice cream here is wonderful! I especially love the pumpkin pie flavor in the fall—it’s the perfect balance of pumpkin without too much nutmeg. The banana cream pie is another favorite of mine. They also offer soft serve, which is great on a hot day. Overall, it’s a solid spot for a sweet treat when you're craving something cool and delicious!

Lovely spot for an ice cream treat or a meal. Lots to choose from and a very friendly staff. The place is immaculate and lots of space in the back to sit outside and relax. Reasonable prices too.

Classic ice cream place with plenty of options and fried food. I had no idea what a corn nugget was at first, but they were well worth the price. Burger was good as well. They have other frozen treats besides ice cream, including frozen cheesecake, ice cream sandwiches, and bananas. If you're in Oneonta, stop by!

Nice place with friendly staff. But the ice creams are too sweet.