Gaetano's Deli

I went to Gaetano’s for the first time this past week. I was talking to a coworker recently about how no place in CT can make a decent chicken cutlet let alone sandwich. I’m originally from Long Island so as you know if you’re from NY that it’s like night and day when it comes to subs or sandwiches. My coworker insisted I try Gaetanos and that I wouldn’t be disappointed. She was not only 100% right about the chicken cutlet and sandwiches but also the staff was 12/10. It’s rare to find a deli with incredible food and incredible staff. Everyone was so kind and generous and made you feel right at home. I will definitely be telling everyone about this place. My dog Jaymo also gives it 5 stars🫶🏼

Given the rave reviews for this deli from both Google and friends, I was reluctant to write a review based on my one time visit. My husband and I shared a pesto chicken sub which appeared delicious, however proved to be quite dry. Hoping to visit again and have a better experience that would permit me to edit this review. If it wasn’t for my high expectations, I’m not sure I would return.

Amazing food! Great quality - no cheap products. And the customer service is spectacular. The manager, Michael, is always very attentive and personable. He remembers everyone’s name and will always make time to engage in conversation despite how busy they are!!! Awesome staff - all the workers are kind and pleasant.

They used to be great now they don’t use the Arthur Avenue bread it was horrible!

Classic spot for great Italian deli sandwiches that never disappoints!