Gabriella’s Old Time Pizza

A quiet little pizzeria with a nostalgic atmosphere. The meatball sub I'd a winner for everyone. The pizza is fabulous, but caution (it stays hot for a moment) . The workers were terrific

I’ve been wanting to try this place for a while, but kept forgetting, then I saw Gabi at my work and it reminded me to order her pizza! The regular crust is thin and a good, crisp texture, not the typical fluffy pizza crust, which is a good thing. I don’t like super fluffy pizza lol. I tried both regular marinara and bold and both are super yummy! I also love the garlic butter and she even gave me some breadsticks to try! They are fluffy and seasoned really well, and come with a yummy cheese sauce. I love her food! Best pizza I’ve had in Indiana! I can’t wait to try the thin crust next time. The owner is super sweet and really cool and she makes the food herself! You’ve got a permanent customer! Thank you so much, Gabi!!!

Not sure about why this is highly rated. I am not sure if i caught them on a bad night. Their "regular" crust is a no go. It was chewy and hard to bite through. I am not one to call and complain, but i wont get again. The pepperoni on the pizza was very good. And their sauce was good. But the crust was so bad, its like, they should warn people. Wont be back. Sad.

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza has more than pizza! Nothing wrong with their pizza, but there's lots of places with good pizza. Instead, my wife and I decided to order sandwiches (meatball, and ham & cheese) which turned out to be really good. We've only ordered a couple times before, and this was the first time we didn't get pizza. I would recommend sandwiches as they are a little different - they had great bread - good crust, but soft inside, toasted and with good melted cheese to ham ratio. There was some cheese that escaped to the crust, adding a crunchy layer which was good. They did serve food with paper plates and Styrofoam cups which seemed a little out of place but it was yummy so we didn't care. The sweet tea was good too, and no need to ask for a to-go cup! This visit we unex

Wow- ate here with my fiancé and baby last night, did not disappoint. Gabriella was so kind and made our visit even better, we ate breadsticks, wings, 1/2 chzburger & 1/2 pepperoni pizza AND had to try the meatball sub… everything was so good I cannot speak on just one item. She offers two different sauces and the one she came up with is so good it’s changed pizza for me. Seems like a smaller town, hopefully she gets the traffic this place deserves! 😋 also super cute place to come in and sit down to eat- loved the atmosphere, rest of the town is tad bit boring.