Forest Avenue Pizza

Quick to get the food out. The marinara Sicilian had a tasty sauce. Crusts are crusty but not cracker. I’d go for the eggplant parm next time. Best part is it feels like your at your aunt and uncles place. Friendly, attentive, and cheerful. Better to come here than across the street. I’ve been to both while visiting folks at the hospital and Forest Ave Pizza was the clear winner.

As someone who works all over the state is one of the best pizza places I've been too. There meatball slice/hero is the best I've ever had and overall all there slices I've tried have been excellent.

The Best Pizza on Long Island I eat here at least once a week. They treat their customers like old friends. I highly recommend you try them you won’t be disappointed

Great pizza and great flavor. I usually go to Ralph’s in Bayville but Forest Pizza is now my spot. Thank you.

I've been eating Forest pizza since the '90s, back when they were across the street. Over the years they've been consistently good. Our family favors the bruschetta and ziti pizza slices. By the slice or by the pie, Forest has some of the best pizza in Glen Cove, and that's saying a lot in a city with about a dozen pizzerias!