Firehouse Bagels Co. 2

Absolutely love this bagel spot. The bagels are always fresh, soft on the inside with that perfect chew on the outside, and you can tell they actually care about quality here. The flavors are on point, the spreads are generous, and everything tastes like it was made the right way—not rushed, not cheap. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and moves efficiently even when it’s busy. You never feel like you’re being rushed, and the vibe is just good—one of those places you actually enjoy stopping into. Portions are solid, prices are fair, and consistency is A+. Definitely one of those places that turns a regular morning into a better one. Highly recommend if you’re a bagel lover or just want a reliable, satisfying bite. 🥯🔥

Wonderful place!! Very clean, delicious food, fair prices, and great service. The Asiago cheese bagel sandwich is now my favorite. Pet friendly!!

I was just there. Their bagels have no flavor & very dry. Couldn’t eat the whole bagel it was that dry. Not a chewy NJ bagel. I’ve been here before. I try it at least 1x per year. I still feel their bagels aren’t good. Customer service was good. The man who helped me was pleasant.

I stopped by Firehouse Bagels and tried the bacon, egg, and cheese—honestly, it was average. What really stood out, though, was the condition of the place. Nearly everything felt either sticky or slippery, which was off-putting. The high chairs were especially filthy and sticky, and it didn’t look like they had been cleaned in a while. There seemed to be a layer of sticky dust coating everything, including the stuffed animals scattered around the shop. I really hope the next time I visit, the cleanliness has improved. The food has potential, but the overall atmosphere made it hard to enjoy the experience.

It's a nice hometown spot with a nice history. I like getting breakfast sandwiches and different types of bagels from there. Portions are generous. The staff are nice and talk to you about your day etc. I definitely recommend it if you're in the area.