Federico's Pizza & Restaurant

Nice variety of slices to choose from. We were not looking to sit down and order off the menu but there were several tables occupied and the food looked fabulous. Will definitely be back.

Excellent lasagna, especially the sauce. Pizza is classic NJ pizza, solid. Service excellent. Very comfortable and pleasant dining area. Located next to St. Rose in center of Belmar.

I ordered a bit before 8 on a Saturday night. The person who took my order over the phone was very rude. Spoke like it was a major inconvenience. When I arrived at the store I stood at the counter for nearly 10 minutes waiting for my order. One of the guys cleaning the floor finally came over and helped me. Food is fine, nothing extraordinary but for the price it was alright. Basically, expect to have less than pleasant experience when you order here.

This had been my go to pizza place for the past year until today. 10/09/25. My mom and I ordered our usual, a large pie with pepperoni. Not only did the pizza come luke warm, we believe it was old and not made fresh. There was also a miscellaneous topping on one of the slices. Sad to say this was a horrible experience. We would have gotten over the fact that the pizza didn't come hot (like it should and usually does), but when I tell you the ingredients tasted stale and strange my mother and I almost immediately and simultaneously said we were never ordering from this establishment again, indefinitely!

The food is always good here- I've never been disappointed. It's kind of a hidden gem for locals. It's reasonably priced, portions are good and one of the B.Y.O.B spots left in town. They're always buddy and most times the service is pretty good too. The staff accommodates your order to whatever requests you may have. They also deliver which makes them even more amazing. Definitely try them out if you haven't.