Fat Boys Creamery

Wandering around the city looking for a late night dessert, so found this place! Don't mind the 'hopefully' under construction Lowes wallpaper exterior. We enjoyed a Cake Batter scoop in a waffle cone (quite a bit of ice cream for one scoop but also it was like $6 or $7 so....) and a coconut milkshake (also pricy at like $8 for the large and it was just them blending soft serve vanilla, milk, and coconut flakes). Still, tasted decent. Service was not the best, with them watching us stare at the screen of flavors for several minutes and then when we went to order - saying they only have the flavors on the paper on the window. So instead of 15 listed flavors ON the digital menu, they only had 6. Why not tell us sooner? So yeah, that is why a low service rating. Low atmosphere as not reall

We Went after a Notre Dame game it was packed and only one employee working so it took awhile but it was well worth it. Amazing and so yummy.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We had the most amazing experience here! My friend and I showed up when it was closed without realizing it, and instead of turning us away, the owners kindly opened up just so we could enjoy some ice cream. That kind of kindness and customer care is rare and meant so much to us. On top of that, the ice cream was absolutely delicious—fresh, creamy, and full of flavor. We left with both happy hearts and happy taste buds. Thank you for going above and beyond—we’ll definitely be back soon!

Shakes were good but there was one person taking orders at both the burger place and the ice cream side, and she was preparing all the ice cream orders. We watched maybe 20 people leave when no one came to take their orders after a long wait. Saturday night after an ND game, you would expect more staff Super sketchy neighborhood. Don’t go at night.

Extremely overpriced, no prices posted. I hardly ever leave poor reviews, but $30 for 4 kids scoops in waffle cones is not worth it. The ice cream itself was adequate. The explanation given was that waffle cones were the same price for kid size, 1, 2 or 3 scoops of the same flavor. Multiple flavors cost extra.