Elizabeth's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Elizabeth's is a small restaurant with a diverse menu, including a few American dishes. We reserved a table for 14 to celebrate my father's 92nd birthday. Even though the restaurant is intimate, they very willingly reserved our seats for us. Our server was extremely attentive, pleasant, and accommodating, as we had six children in tow. Our server was extra kind to my father, and very sweetly served him a piece of cheesecake at the end of the meal. Our menu choices varied from an Italian hamburger to pizza, chicken parm, fried mushrooms, loaded french fries, and minestrone soup. Everything we tasted was delicious! The portions allowed us to take leftovers home. Overall, a wonderful dining experience in beautiful Pittsboro.

Very nice restaurant, with some outdoor and indoor seating. Katie took care of us and was super friendly and nice. We had pizza, cheese bread and garlic knots. Everything was very good, we will definitely be back! There is also a very cool antique type store next door that is worth checking out.

Having moved from New York recently, we have been searching for an Italian restaurant or at least good tasting Italian food, Elizabeth's in Pittsboro is the best tasting so far. My husband is Italian and he gave a double thumbs up! Food is delicious, pizza dough is the closest to New York pizza, we also had some entrees that were delicious, good portions, reasonably/ honestly priced and the service is fast and friendly. We met Hailey on our last visit and she was very friendly, good and attentive. Family friendly, just very comfortable. We cannot wait for our next visit! Thank you for offering such good food in a friendly environment. Btw, The bathrooms were spotless.

Pleasant surprise, a simple place yet very homey. My husband is Italian and he knows his food. The eggplant Parmesan was smoky and delicious, the Cajun style jumbo shrimp pasta was very good, fresh and crunchy. Karen went above and beyond to make us feel at home. I haven’t taste my cannoli but looks so good. We will be back!

My boyfriend and I had dinner on January 20th, 2025. When I had called to make reservations, I asked for a booth. When we got there, our booth was marked with a reserved sign/tag which I was happy about. My parents and I had ate here before and got take out, but it was my boyfriend’s first time. He was impressed with the fancy dishes on the menu. He got a chicken francese dish I believe and he absolutely loved it! I ordered the fried mushroom appetizer that comes with ranch sauce. It was great! For my entree, I ordered the slice of New York style pizza with fresh garlic and jalapeños. I said light on the jalepenos and to make the pizza crisp. When our server brought it out, it was just as I had ordered it! The pizza was delicious!! You could taste the fresh garlic too and the presentat